twitter: @rolygate

Bill Godshall Update 2015-10-16

Tobacco Harm Reduction Update - October 16th, 2015

THR Surveillance

2015 Welsh Health Survey finds 16% of current smokers, 8% of ex-smokers, and 0% of never smokers currently use e-cigs; finds 48% of current smokers, 13% of ex-smokers, and 1% of never smokers have ever used an e-cig. (see page 6)

Questions raised over whether e-cigarettes lead to smoking after Wales survey can’t find a single regular user that has never smoked

Wales’ Chief Medical Officer reports record low weekly smoking rates for teens (8% of 15/16 year old boys, 9% for girls) and record low drinking rates (as vaping increases), but Welsh government still plans to ban vaping

Scotland’s NHS reports 31% drop in number of smoking cessation products it dispensed during past year; Health Minister Maureen Watt said decline could be partly attributed to "the increasing use of electronic cigarettes as an alternative aid to stopping smoking."

US TTB data shows taxed tobacco consumption in 1st 7 months of 2015 (versus 2014):
- Cigarettes increased 0.8% (from 150 to 151 billion sticks)
- Small Cigars decreased 5.3% (from 315 to 299 million)
- Large Cigars decreased 26.7% (from 3.97 to 2.91 billion)
- Snuff increased 2.0% (from 66.1 to 67.5 million pounds)
- Chewing Tobacco decreased 9.1% (from 12.5 to 11.5 million pounds)
- Pipe Tobacco decreased 4.3% (from 22 to 21 million pounds) (most is used for RYO)
- RYO Tobacco decreased 0.1% (from 1.9 to 1.9 million pounds)

Consumer analyst Vivian Azer attributes slight US cigarette increase to falling gasoline prices, while UC’s Anna Song absurdly hypothesizes (despite all evidence and common sense to the contrary) that e-cigs increase cigarette smoking, and insultingly compares those who think e-cigs aren’t harmful with those who think cigarettes aren’t harmful.

Prohibition vs Public Health

Clive Bates: Harms or highs? Regulating narcotics, alcohol and nicotine

After study estimates 1/3rd of Chinese men will die from cigarette smoking,
WHO director Margaret Chan urges China and other countries to ban lifesaving e-cigs “E-cigarettes will prompt young people to take up smoking. I recommend that national governments ban, or at least regulate, them"; Beijing Tobacco Control Association also demonizes vapor products.

Clive Bates: WHO’s Director General’s casual irresponsibility promotes death and disease through protecting the cigarette trade

FDA Deeming Reg/Ban

FDLI conference October 21 on FDA’s proposed deeming regulation (that would ban >99.9% of nicotine vapor products 24 months after issuance of the Final Rule); several THR advocates and many e-cig prohibitionists and propagandists invited to present

Former FDA Deputy Cmsnr Josh Sharfstein (who implemented and defended FDA’s unlawful 2009 e-cig ban, and falsely claimed e-cigs don’t help people quit smoking, were target marketed to youth, were addicting nonsmoking youth and were gateways to cigarettes, and falsely insinuated e-cigs are toxic and carcinogenic) promotes FDA’s proposed Deeming reg/ban (that would ban >99.9% of nicotine vapor products) by claiming the agency doesn’t have to implement disastrous federal regulations it imposes.

CSP interviews PAX Labs CEO James Monsees endorses FDA deeming regulation (that would ban 99.9% of nicotine vapor products now on the market).


Clive Bates: Totally Wicked legal challenge to the Tobacco Products Directive e-cigarette measures

Charles Muspratt: EU chooses corporatism on E-cigarettes (but author falsely accuses tobacco companies of lobbying for EU TPD, as it was Tobacco Control Extremists)

EU adopts TPD specifications for color graphic warnings on cigarette packages

THR Education / Advocacy

Richard Smith: How public health moralists are promoting harm from tobacco

Polosa/Campagna/Caponnetto: What to advise to respiratory patients intending to use electronic cigarettes

Sally Satel: How vapers can help smokers quit

New Zealand Vaping Alliance Launched

CDC acknowledges that needle exchange programs save lives of heroin addicts, but still refuses to admit that lifesaving vapor products save lives of cigarette smokers

THR Censorship

Facebook bans promotion of A Billion Lives, claims forthcoming movie (about smokers quitting smoking by switching to vaping) promotes tobacco products

Vapor Product Standards

ISO rejects proposal by French standardization organization AFNOR to establish new technical committee for “vape and vapour products” separate from existing committee for “tobacco products”

THR Business and Industry

SFATA board appoints Executive Director Cynthia Cabrera to its Board of Directors, and appoints her as next President and CEO

SFATA holds election for board of directors

Reynolds announces four new Vuse e-cig flavors (crema, chai, berry and mint)

Philip Morris International reports 1.5% cigarette shipment decline in 3Q15

CSP interviews Mistic VP John Weisehan III about new Craft Collection vaporizers


FDA launches $128 million abstinence-only anti-tobacco program targeting hip-hop youth

FDA’s Hip-Hop Anti Smoking Campaign: Brilliant or Doomed to Fail?


SEATCA wisely advocates cigarette tax increases in SE Asian countries, but counterproductively advocates higher tax rates on less harmful tobacco products

CA Senate bill (SBX2 14) to tax e-cigs read second time, ordered to third reading (requires 2/3rds vote for passage, and is unlikely to pass)

CA tobacco and vapor tax hike proponents and profiteers send ballot initiative language to AGs office

Billionaire environmental fear monger Tom Steyer spending for California cigarette, OTP and vapor tax ballot initiative

ATR: Hypocritical “Save Lives” coalition proposes tax on life-saving tobacco alternative (California)

Big Pharma funded CTFK’s Matt Myers wisely advocates increasing PA’s cigarette tax rate, but deceitfully claims similar tax rates on low risk e-cigs, smokeless tobacco and cigars benefit public health

Debate over e-cigarettes dominates Indiana legislative hearing

Lawsuit Abuse

California State Attorney General seeks to curb Prop 65 abuse

Tobacco/Vapor Product Sales Ban

Bill introduced in Philadelphia City Council would ban sale of tobacco and vapor products at pharmacies, Mayer Nutter endorses; public hearing scheduled for Oct 22

Retailer Regulations

After proposing unwarranted vaping ban that protect cigarette markets, Snohomish (WA) Health District proposes cigarette protecting vapor product retailer regulations that would ban employees from vaping in vape shops, ban vaping in vape shops except for sampling, ban furniture and TVs from vape shops, mandate HVAC air cleaners in vape shops, and create a two tier vape shop licensing system with large annual fees.

Packaging Restrictions

NJ Senate Health Cmte to hold October 19 public hearing on bill (S 2877) to require child resistant packaging for e-liquid

OH House Health and Aging Cmte holds October 14 hearing on child resistant e-liquid packaging bill (SB 54)

Vapor Product Sales Ban to Minors

CA Governor Brown signs bill (AB 216) banning sales of nonnicotine vapor products to minors under 18 years

Tobacco Sales Ban to Minors

MI Senate unanimously approves bill (SB 340) to impose significantly higher fines for tobacco sales to minors, but bill doesn’t ban vapor product sales to minors.

Minimum Age Laws

US Senate Dems want to raise minimum age for tobacco sales to 21

Healdsburg (CA) City Council suspends recently enacted law to increase legal minimum age for tobacco and vapor product sales to 21 years, Mayor claims council acted because NATO was preparing to sue the city.

Vaping bans

Maine vaping ban goes into effect Oct 15, bill’s sponsor makes more false claims about vaping and the vaping ban

Lemon Grove (CA) City Council bans vaping despite no evidence it poses risks to public

Wheaton (IL) City Council bans vaping where smoking is banned

Bill to restrict “vaping” moves forward in Prince Georges County (MD)

Vapor Product Possession Ban for Minors

Illinios Senate refers bill (SB 32) (banning youth from possessing an alternative nicotine product and imposing incremental fines, mandatory community services and/or “smoker’s education” or “youth diversion” programs for violators) to Assignments Cmte.

Smokeless Tobacco Usage Ban

CA Gov. Brown signs bill (AB 768) that intolerantly bans adults from using very low risk smokeless tobacco at professional baseball stadia (despite no harm or risks to nonusers)

Staff of CA legislator who sponsored the smokeless tobacco usage ban in baseball stadia acknowledges the law won’t be enforced, AP reporter repeats fear mongering claims about low risk smokeless tobacco and MLB’s influence on youth use (which is far greater in rural America than in any of the metropolitan areas with a MLB baseball team).

Vaping Research

Study finds cigarettes, but not nicotine free e-cigs, emit huge levels of carbon monoxide

Smokeless Tobacco Research

Study finds acrylamide exposure from smokeless tobacco dwarfed by dietary exposure or smking

JAMA’s False “Gateway to Smoking” Allegations

JAMA publishes another fraudulent “gateway” study by DHHS funded Primack et al, this time claiming hookah and snus are gateways to cigarettes (because some teens and young adults tried hookah or snus before smoking their first cigarette) to confuse, scare and lobby for FDA’s deeming regulation (that would ban >99.9% of e-cigs and hookahs).

JAMA invites editorial by two NYU extremist who cite fraudulent JAMA gateway studies to falsely claim e-cigs, hookah and OTP are gateways to cigarette smoking and lobby for FDA’s proposed deeming regulation

NYU press release repeats false claims in JAMA articles and editorials about e-cigs and hookah to lobby for FDA deeming regulation

Vapor Emissions Junk Science

Study finds median of 572.52 ug/m3 of PM2.5 air pollution in homes of cigarette smokers compared to 9.88mg/m3 in homes of e-cig vapers, and 9.53 and 9.36 mg/m3 in homes of nonsmokers (see Figure 2); but abstract never mentioned the exponentially greater PM2.5 levels found in smokers’ homes, then deceitfully insinuated the negligible difference of 0.5 mg/m3 of PM2.5 (between vapers’ and nonsmokers’ homes) was toxic by concluding “e-cigarettes used under real-conditions emit toxicants, including PM2.5”.

Note the National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) for PM2.5 is 35ug/m3
and the Air Quality Index classifies PM2.5 above 250ug/m3 is classified as “Severe”

Konstantinos Farsalinos: A new study reports that e-cigarettes emit toxins to the environment but the authors did not really find any…

AVA: New Vaping Study Slammed by Researchers for “Severe Bias”

Mike Siegel: New article demonstrates severe bias by anti-tobacco researchers in the communication of scientific results about e-cigarettes

NEJM’s Fraudulent Low Nicotine Cigarette Claim

Theodore Dalrymple : Significant flaw in study claiming that decreasing nicotine content of cigarettes reduced smoking

Another news story repeats false claims by NEJM, NIDA, UCSF, Vanderbilt, Pitt, Donney et al about low nicotine cigarette study (which found no cigarette consumption decline by smokers given low nicotine cigarettes and paid $835), ALA’s Pat McKone and another vaping opponent falsely claim e-cigs may be as harmful as cigarettes.

More Junk Science, Propaganda and Lies

Mike Siegel – Bias in anti-tobacco movement is laid bare: if you don’t quit the way we want you to quit, then don’t bother

Mike Siegel exposes Stan Glantz insincerity and hypocrisy for endorsing reduced cigarette consumption if harmful low nicotine cigarettes are used (but not if far less harmful vapor or smokeless tobacco products are used); but Siegel inaccurately and absurdly refers to vapor prohibitionist Glantz as an “anti smoking researcher”.

Irish cardiac consultant Tony Moloney falsely claims there is no evidence e-cigs are less harmful than cigarettes

Mike Siegel – American Lung Association: Real cigarettes are no more hazardous than fake ones

Australian snus and e-cig prohibitionist Simon Chapman keeps lying about vaping to discourage smokers from quitting smoking

Mike Siegel: CDC continues to mislead the public by classifying e-cigarettes as tobacco products and not admitting they contain no tobacco

Financial Times and Herald Scotland headline and article misrepresent THR advocate Linda Bauld’s views about vapor product advertising and marketing, Bauld responds

Trans Pacific Partnership (TPP)

Simon Lester: Will tobacco kill the Trans Pacific Partnership?

Tobacco carve out sparks bid to sink TPP

Tobacco draws a fight on trade deal

Growers alarmed by planned TPP carve-out

Understanding the TPP: Investor-State Dispute Settlement

New York Times runs second tobacco smear article against US Chamber of Commerce in past month (Sept 18 article)

US Chamber of Commerce responds to NY Times’ demonization of chamber