twitter: @rolygate

Bill Godshall Update 2016-02-26

Tobacco Harm Reduction Update - February 26th, 2016


War on Vaping, THR Education, US Budget, US Congress, US Politics, US FDA, DHHS Funded Lobbying For FDA Vapor Product Deeming Ban, US Government Financed Cigarettes, US Tobacco Business, Litigation, Taxation, Vaping Ban, Vaping/Smoking Ban, Minimum Age Laws, More Government Funded Lobbying, Health Board Accountability, UK, EU TPD, Australia, Scientific Research on Vapor Products, Battery Safety, Junk Science, Propaganda and Lies.

Subscribe to THR Update email:
- send email to Bill Godshall with SUBSCRIBE as the subject:
billgodshall[AT]verizon[DOT]net [replace with @ and .net]


War on Vaping

You are being lied to: A Billion Lives
Documentary exposes the dirty truth about the War on Vaping

THR Education

UK National Centre for Smoking Cessation and Training issues 48 page report with accurate and objective information on nicotine and health benefits of vapor products; Electronic Cigarettes: A briefing for stop smoking services

Most e-cigarette use 'to help smokers quit' (UK)

E-cigarettes could be behind sharp rise of successful attempts to quit smoking (UK)

New Nicotine Alliance’s Sarah Jakes: The Pleasure Priniciple (UK)

Vape shop provides less harmful alternatives for smokers (OR)

US Budget

Obama’s budget proposal would increase cigarette tax from $1.01 to $1.95/pack, increase tax for low risk smokeless tobacco by 800% and for pipe tobacco by 1,500% (so they are taxed at same rate as far more harmful cigarettes), double cigar tax

US Congress

Joel Nitzkin: HR 2058 and the regulation of e-cigarettes

CASAA urges vapers to contact their US Representative urging support for HR 2058

Representative Tom Cole’s (R-OK) HR 2058 is gaining political support for vaping (now has 48 cosponsors)

US Politics

Grover Norquist on C-Span: Vaping and the Changing Electorate in 2016


US Senate confirms Robert Califf as FDA Commissioner

DHHS Secretary Burwell falsely claims the FDA (whose cigarette protecting Deeming Regulation would ban >99.9% of lifesaving vapor products) has an “unsurpassed record of protecting public health while encouraging innovation” in press release praising US Senate confirmation of Dr. Robert Califf as FDA Commissioner.

FDA announces so-called workshop on Waterpipes and Waterpipe Tobacco March 17/18
(but note that February 25 is deadline for registering to attend, to speak during public comment period or to listen/watch webinar online; public comment deadline April 29).!documentDetail;D=FDA-2016-N-0173-0001

FDA funded and dominated 2016 SRNT Conference Abstracts at

DHHS Funded Lobbying For FDA Vapor Product Deeming Ban

Brad Rodu: Imaginary hobgoblins from e-cigarette liquid lab tests

News article touts NIH funded Ilano Jaspers junk science, claims about vaping at AAAS

Mike Siegel: Scientist tells AAAS convention that electronic cigarettes are just as dangerous as real ones

NCI funded study deceitfully equates lethal cigarettes with and lifesaving vapor products, low risk cigars and hookah to lobby for FDA’s cigarette protecting Deeming ban

US and Florida funded activists tell news media waterpipes are gateways to cigarettes to lobby for FDA deeming ban, but their study found no evidence as questions merely asked participants if they might smoke cigarettes in the future

Carl Phillips: Serious ethical concerns about public health research conduct; the case of vape convention air quality measurement

Clive Bates: What was unethical about snoopers measuring particulates at a vape convention

US Government Financed Cigarettes

22nd Century, which sold millions of low nicotine cigarettes to the US government and is relying on FDA for future revenue and profits, reports $11 million loss in 2015, and $15.6 million loss in 2014

US Tobacco Business

Are surging cigarette sales putting burn on MST? What’s really going on in the smokeless catagory


MA judge awards $4.9 million plus interest to a class of nearly 200,000 Marlboro Lights smokers (the plaintiffs were seeking $600 million)

New York Court rules that vaping is not smoking (duh), confirming that NY state’s
smoking ban does NOT ban vaping


Boehm: States reach for cigarette taxes to ease budgetary worries, but problems loom

WV Senate approves bill (SB 420) to impose $.075/ml tax on all e-liquid (i.e. $2.25 for a 30ml bottle) including nicotine-free e-liquid, increase cigarette tax from $.55 to $1.55/ pack, and increase OTP tax from 7% to 12%.

CASAA urges Utah vapers to oppose proposed 86.5% tax on vapor products

Previously untaxed e-cigarettes may face 86.5% tax in Utah

Utah politician Paul Ray slammed for claiming e-cigarettes cause cancer

Utah SFATA’s Shilo Pitts: Vaping industry shares Utahn’s goals for reducing youth tobacco use

CASAA urges Alaska vapers to oppose Gov. Walker’s proposed 100% tax on lifesaving vapor products (AK House public hearing February 24)

CASAA urges Hawaii vapers to oppose bill (SB 2961) to impose 80% tax on vapor products

Note that Hawaii Vapers United on FB closely tracks anti vaping legislation in HI

Maryland bill (HB 861) would impose 30% tax on vapor products, ban vaping in workplaces, deceitfully redefine a smokefree vapor products as “smoking devices”,
public hearing scheduled March 2.

CASAA urges Maryland vapers to oppose bill to ban vaping and tax vapor products

Small businesses and Chicago Aldermen criticize Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s bill to increase tobacco taxes, increase minimum age for tobacco and vapor product sales to 21, and impose $10,000 fines for selling single cigarettes.

Thomas Briant: Chicago’s tobacco ordinance about small business, not Big Tobacco

Vaping Ban

CASAA urges Vermont vapers to oppose bill (H 171) to ban vaping in workplaces

Vaping/Smoking Ban

NJ Assembly Cmte approves bill (A 893) cosponsored by Legacy board member Herb Conaway to ban vaping and smoking on all state and local forests, parks and beaches, criticize Gov. Christy for wisely vetoing same bill last year

Minimum Age Laws

CASAA urges Utah vapers to oppose bill (HB 157) that would increase the minimum age for sales of lifesaving vapor products from 19 to 21 (and would also apply to deadly cigarettes and low risk OTP).

NJ Assembly Cmte approves bill (A 2320) (sponsored by Legacy board member Herb Conaway) to increase minimum age for sales of lifesaving vapor products, deadly cigarettes and low risk OTP from 19 to 21 years (to deceive public to believe vapor, smokeless tobacco and OTP are just as hazardous as cigarettes).

Illinois bill (SB 3011) would raise legal minimum age for vapor and tobacco sales to 21

American Heart Association deceitfully claims teen smoking is increasing, makes many other false claims to lobby for legislation to raise San Francisco’s legal minimum age for sale of lifesaving vapor products, deadly cigarettes and low risk OTP to 21.

More Government Funded Lobbying

South Carolina gives Big Pharma shill ALA $10,000 to demonize vapor products and OTP, lobby to ban vaping and smokeless tobacco use throughout the state$10000-smokefree-grant

NY government financed program Reality Check organizes youth to lobby to ban smoking in movies, claim doing so would reduce smoking (despite no evidence).

Health Board Accountability

WV bill (HB 4472) would allow County Commissions to revoke local Health Board Rules (including unwarranted vaping bans)

WV House Cmte rejects 12-10 a bill (HB 4472) that would have allowed County Commissions to revoke Health Board rules (including unwarranted vaping bans)


UK Advertising Standards Authority, which has banned truthful vapor product ads, defends false and gruesome anti-smoking ad by Public Health England

Study finds UK tobacco display ban, that created longer waiting times for customers, did NOT reduce cigarette smoking (as law’s advocates had previously insisted would occur)


Keller and Heckman attorneys Azim Chowdhury and Marcus Navin-Jones will host a complimentary webinar for complying with EU TPD e-cigarette regulations on February 29th from 12:00-1:00 EST; to register go to

Clive Bates: Totally Wicked case: Advocate General’s flawed reasoning would protect the cigarette trade

E-Quits Limited’s David Extance says EU TPD could devastate vapor industry (UK)

ASH-UK defends, downplays EU TPD’s cigarette protecting regulations for e-cigarettes


South Australian Vapers petition parliamentary committee to legalize sale of lifesaving vapor products

South Australia Parliamentary Cmte denies scientific evidence, protects cigarettes by proposing laws to ban vaping, and to ban ads and promotions for vapor products

Scientific Research On Vapor Products

Mayo Clinic: E-cigarettes mitigate risks of smoking before and after operations

Protocol proposal for, and evaluation of, consistency in nicotine delivery from the liquid to the aerosol of electronic cigarette atomizers: regulatory implications

How to measure nicotine delivery from e-cigarettes; New protocol anticipates EU TPD taking effect May 2016

BAT’s Marina Murphy: Assessing the safety and evaluating the risk of novel tobacco and nicotine products

Battery Safety

Jack Smith: There is only one reason vapes, hoverboards and drones keep exploding

Junk Science, Propaganda and Lies

After acknowledging that vaping has helped many smokers quit smoking, Robert West falsely claims “there really isn’t any good evidence that it has any benefit” for reducing harm among vapers who don’t completely quit smoking (despite massive evidence to the contrary), criticizes MHRA approval of BAT e-Voke as a medicine after he urged MHRA to impose the unwarranted medicine regulation on lifesaving vapor products.

NTR editor says private sector funding (i.e. by tobacco, drug, vapor companies) of vapor research raises conflicts of interest, while remaining silent about Obama’s Billion Dollar War on Vaping and THR; proposes replicating Shiffman et al study finding adult smokers are more interested in flavored vapor products than teen nonsmokers.
Marcus Munafo: Conflicts of Interest and Solicited Replication Attempts

Carl Phillips: SRNT believes research should be replicated (when they don’t like the results)

Brad Rodu – 'Through With Chew' week: Don’t be fooled

Legacy lies initiative falsely claims US DOT banned vaping on airlines

US DOT’s proposed rule to ban smoking of smokefree e-cigarettes on airlines is at!documentDetail;D=DOT-OST-2011-0044-0003

Washington Post publishes cigarette protecting propaganda from Consumer Reports that contains many false and misleading fear mongering claims about vaping

Guy Bentley – Paper: E-cigarette policy often based on blind faith in poor research

Julia Belluz’ otherwise excellent VOX article (with a spot-on title) about ethics and health science journalism touts straw man arguments of the unknown to demonize vaping (while ignoring the known evidence confirming vaping’s health benefits for smokers).
Why reporting on health and science is a good way to lose friends and alienate people
“Take e-cigarettes. We described all the research there and found some important limitations - for example, there are no published long-term studies of the health effects of vaping to date. We have no idea what vapor and the chemicals in e-cigs will do to the lungs or other parts of the body in the long term.”

Vaping prohibitionist Stan Glantz now absurdly claims movies that show smoking cause lung cancer like mosquitos transmit zika virus


- Bill Godshall

Godshall THR update 2016-02-26